Tick Product Comparison

American Dog Tick 2

Brown Dog Tick single

Adult Female Lone Star Tick

blackleggd tick

American Dog Tick,
Vector of: Rocky Mountain Spotted Fever

Brown Dog Tick,
Vector of: Ehrlichiosis

Lone Star Tick (note the "star" on the belly),
Vector of: Rocky Mountain Spotted Fever

Deer Tick or Black-legged tick,
Vector of: Lyme disease (Borrelia burgdorferi), and Anaplasmosis (Anaplasma platys)

Confused about tick protection? This FAQ compares the currently available tick control products to assist you in determining which is right for your situation. These are products made by reputable major pharmaceutical companies and most are available only through licensed veterinarians. Because there are 13 different products compared in 14 different categories, we have split up the information into 3 separate tables

Table 1:

Tick killing ingredient; Format (topical, collar or spray); For dogs or cats; Approved against which ticks
Youngest age or size approved for use; How long one application lasts
 

Table 2:

Waterproof or water resistant; Approved for pregnancy or lactation (nursing); How long until maximum effect against ticks is reached; Other parasites killed, controlled or repelled; Other active ingredients
 

Table 3:

Prescription drug or insecticide; LD50 (lethal dose to 50% of the population);
Manufacturer and product website; Additional cautions

TABLE 1

Tick Killing Ingredient

Format

For dogs
or cats?

Approved against which ticks

Youngest Age Approved

How long One Application Lasts

K9Advantix

Permethrin

Topical

Dogs only

all shown above

7 weeks

1 month

Revolution

Selamectin

Topical

Feline product available but not labeled against ticks

American Dog Tick only

6 weeks

1 month

Scalibor Collar

Deltamethrin

Collar

Dogs only

Brown Dog Tick, American Dog Tick, and Deer Ticks

12 weeks

6 months

Preventic Collar

Amitraz

Collar

Dogs only

all shown above

12 weeks

up to 90 days

Frontline,
Fiproguard, PetArmor, EasySpot
(cats),
Parastar (dogs)

Fipronil

Topical or spray

Dogs and Cats

all shown above

8 weeks

1 month

Vectra 3D,
SimpleGuard 3*,
FirstShield Trio*

Permethrin

Topical

Dogs only (feline product does not include a tick ingredient)

all shown above

7 weeks
and 2.5 lbs

1 month

Certifect

Fipronil and Amitraz

Topical

Dogs only

all shown above

8 weeks
and 5 lbs

1 month

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

TABLE 2

Waterproof or
water resistant?

Approved for Pregnancy and Lactation?

Time to Reach Maximum Effect

Other parasites controlled or repelled:

Other active ingredients:

K9Advantix

water resistant

No

98% dead within 48 hours

fleas, flies, mosquitoes

imidocloprid

Revolution

water proof

Yes

48 hours

ear mites, fleas, sarcoptic mange mites, heartworm

none

Scalibor Collar

water resistant (remove collar for bathing)

Not specifically labeled against, veterinary consultation recommended

2 - 3 weeks

fleas killed, flies and mosquitoes repelled

none

Preventic Collar

water resistant (remove collar for bathing)

Not specifically labeled against, veterinary consultation recommended

100% dead in less than 24 hours

none

none

Frontline,
Fiproguard, PetArmor, EasySpot
(cats),
Parastar (dogs)

water proof

Yes for topspot, no for spray

24 - 48 hours

fleas

methoprene
in Frontline Plus,
Fiproguard Plus
and PetArmor Plus

Vectra 3D
SimpleGuard 3*,
FirstShield Trio*

water resistant

No

98% dead within 48 hours

fleas, flies, mosquitoes

dinotefuran, pyriproxifen (former kills fleas, latter sterilizes them until former product kills them)

Certifect

water resistant

Yes

18 hours

fleas

methoprene

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


 

 

 

TABLE 3

Prescription Drug or Insecticide?

Toxicity/LD 50
(what is LD 50?)

Manufacturer & product web site

Additional Cautions

K9Advantix

insecticide

Imidacloprid Dermal Dose:
>5,000 mg/kg in rats
Imidacloprid Orally: 450 mg/kg in rats
>4,000 mg/kg in rats for Permethrin

Bayer

Permethrin is toxic to cats, use feline product only for cats. Avoid cat/dog snuggling.

Revolution

prescription drug

>1,600 mg/kg in rats

Pfizer

Dog should test negative for heartworm before using

Scalibor Collar

insecticide

oral LD 50 for dogs is 300 mg/kg,
the dermal LD 50 in the rat is
greater than 2,940 mg/kg

Merck

Deltamethrin is toxic to cats. Avoid cat/dog snuggling.

Preventic Collar

insecticide

> 2,000 mg/kg in rats for Amitraz

Virbac

Amitraz is associated with an assortment of drug interactions, check with your vet. Also, collar is toxic if swallowed.

Frontline,
Fiproguard,
PetArmor, EasySpot (cats),
Parastar (dogs)

insecticide

Fipronil Dermal Dose:
>5,000 mg/kg in rats
Fipronil Orally: 750 mg/kg in rats
Methoprene Orally: >34,600 in rats (virtually non-toxic)

Merial
Sentry
Fidopharm
Novartis
Novartis

none

Vectra 3D
SimpleGuard 3*,
FirstShield Trio*

insecticide

>2,400 mg/kg in rats for Dinotefuran,
>4,000 mg/kg in rats for topical Permethrin

Summit

Permethrin is toxic to cats, use feline product only for cats. Avoid cat/dog snuggling.

Certifect

insecticide

> 2,000 mg/kg in rats for Amitraz
Fipronil Dermal Dose:
>5,000 mg/kg in rats
Fipronil Orally: 750 mg/kg in rats

Merial

Amitraz is associated with an assortment of drug interactions

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

As of spring 2011, Pfizer has discontinued the manufacture of Promeris (active ingredients: amitraz and metaflumizone)

* VCA Animal Hospitals and Banfield Pet Hospitals market some products under their own hospital private label, made by the
   same manufacterer as the original product. It is the same product (made by the same manufacturer) but with a different name.

For general tick information including how to remove ticks, U.S. maps showing prevalence of tick-borne disease, and other general information, please visit:     www.dogsandticks.com

Page posted: 7/25/2011
Page last revised: 3/18/2012